Articles / 10 Biggest Oilers Draft Busts Since 2000

10 Biggest Oilers Draft Busts Since 2000

T
The Hockey Writers
Sep 13, 2025 3:48 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →

The Edmonton Oilers have had a number of draft selections since 2000 that didn’t pan out as hoped, leading to considerable frustration among fans and management alike. This list of the ten biggest draft busts showcases the players who were expected to excel in the NHL but ultimately failed to deliver. Names such as Jesse Puljujärvi and Magnus Paajarvi are prominent examples of high expectations falling flat.

Jesse Puljujärvi was the fourth overall pick in 2016, hailed for his offensive skills. However, after several seasons filled with inconsistency and not living up to his first-round status, he became a symbol of the Oilers' drafting woes. Similarly, Magnus Paajarvi, selected 10th overall in 2009, was initially seen as a promising prospect, yet he struggled to secure a lasting position with the team and has since moved around various franchises.

Another notorious name is Justin Schultz, who the Oilers chose in the second round of the 2008 draft. His time in Edmonton was marred by defensive issues and a lack of growth, prompting a shift to the Pittsburgh Penguins where he finally began to find success. These stories highlight a keen issue with player development and scouting that has plagued the Oilers over the years.

As the Oilers continue to focus on building a championship-caliber team, the ghosts of past drafts cast a long shadow. Fans can only hope that recent picks will break the cycle of disappointment, as the team aims to learn from its missteps and improve its future strategies.