5 Most Overrated NHL General Managers for 2025-26
T
The Hockey Writers
Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →
In the 2025-26 NHL season, several general managers have faced scrutiny for their decision-making and team-building strategies. Notably, the performances of the Toronto Maple Leafs under Kyle Dubas have come under fire, especially with the team's failure to capitalize on a talented roster. Critics argue that Dubas' reliance on analytics over traditional scouting has led to questionable roster moves, ultimately impacting the team's playoff success.
Meanwhile, Jim Benning of the Vancouver Canucks is highlighted as another overrated GM, whose inconsistent player acquisitions and contract decisions have left the team in a precarious position. The Canucks have struggled with salary cap issues and have not seen the desired development from their young players. This has sparked debates about whether Benning is the right person to lead the franchise into a more competitive era.
Additionally, there is concern over the direction taken by Kevin Cheveldayoff of the Winnipeg Jets, whose team has not met expectations despite having a solid core, including star players. Cheveldayoff’s hesitance to make bold trades has frustrated fans, as many believe the Jets have the potential to contend for a Cup if properly managed. The need for a fresh perspective is evident as critical voices grow louder.
Finally, the article mentions the Chicago Blackhawks' general manager, whose controversial decisions have not resonated well with the fanbase. With the recent decline in the team’s performance, it becomes imperative for the GM to reassess their approach and make impactful changes to revitalize the struggling franchise.
Meanwhile, Jim Benning of the Vancouver Canucks is highlighted as another overrated GM, whose inconsistent player acquisitions and contract decisions have left the team in a precarious position. The Canucks have struggled with salary cap issues and have not seen the desired development from their young players. This has sparked debates about whether Benning is the right person to lead the franchise into a more competitive era.
Additionally, there is concern over the direction taken by Kevin Cheveldayoff of the Winnipeg Jets, whose team has not met expectations despite having a solid core, including star players. Cheveldayoff’s hesitance to make bold trades has frustrated fans, as many believe the Jets have the potential to contend for a Cup if properly managed. The need for a fresh perspective is evident as critical voices grow louder.
Finally, the article mentions the Chicago Blackhawks' general manager, whose controversial decisions have not resonated well with the fanbase. With the recent decline in the team’s performance, it becomes imperative for the GM to reassess their approach and make impactful changes to revitalize the struggling franchise.