Articles / 5 Reasons the Oilers Haven’t Won the Stanley Cup in the Connor McDavid Era

5 Reasons the Oilers Haven’t Won the Stanley Cup in the Connor McDavid Era

T
The Hockey Writers
Aug 18, 2025 3:00 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →

The Edmonton Oilers, despite having generational talent like Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, have struggled to secure a Stanley Cup during the Connor McDavid era. One of the main reasons for this is the team's inconsistency on defense. The Oilers have often relied heavily on their star forwards to outscore opponents, which has created vulnerabilities at the back end. This reliance has been a critical factor in their playoff shortcomings, especially when facing teams with strong defensive structures.

Another significant issue has been the lack of depth in their lineup. While McDavid and Draisaitl can carry the team for stretches, the Oilers have often been exposed when key players have underperformed or faced injuries. Supporting players need to step up in clutch moments, but there has been a recurring trend of not enough offensive contributions from the bottom six forwards. This lack of depth becomes apparent in tight playoff series, affecting the team's overall performance.

Moreover, the Oilers have also faced challenges with their goaltending. With inconsistency between the pipes, the team has struggled to find a reliable starter who can handle the pressures of the playoffs. The performance of the goaltender can often be the difference in a playoff series, and the Oilers have been on the wrong side of this equation in recent years.

Finally, the Oilers have not always been able to adapt their game strategy when it matters the most. In crucial games, they have occasionally stuck to their offensive-heavy game plan instead of adjusting to the needs of the moment. This lack of adaptability can be costly during the playoff grind, where matchups and strategies can change rapidly. As the Oilers look to find their way to the top, addressing these issues will be key to their championship aspirations.