Articles / Are Maple Leafs suffering from buyer's remorse with Carlo trade?

Are Maple Leafs suffering from buyer's remorse with Carlo trade?

S
Sportsnet
Nov 10, 2025 11:32 AM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Sportsnet. Read the full original article here →

The recent trade of Carlo to the Toronto Maple Leafs has sparked a wave of speculation among fans and analysts alike. While the Leafs have added depth to their defense with Carlo's solid two-way game, some are questioning whether the price paid was too high. Carlo's presence is expected to enhance the team's playoff chances, but the uncertainty surrounding the trade has left supporters feeling uneasy.

In the first few games since the trade, the Maple Leafs have shown glimpses of improved defensive cohesion, but inconsistencies remain. Analysts point out that while Carlo has been effective, the team still struggles with critical moments in games. Some fans feel that there may be a tinge of buyer's remorse as they reflect on the long-term impact of this move on the franchise.

Despite the initial excitement, veteran players like John Tavares and Auston Matthews remain under pressure to lead the team through this transition. As they adapt to their new lineup, the stakes are high for the Maple Leafs, who aim to break their playoff curse and make a deep playoff run. The upcoming games will be pivotal in determining whether the Carlo trade was a savvy move or a misstep for the organization.