Articles / Are the Maple Leafs' struggles tied more to Matthews or Berube?

Are the Maple Leafs' struggles tied more to Matthews or Berube?

S
Sportsnet
Nov 4, 2025 5:08 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Sportsnet. Read the full original article here →

The struggles of the Toronto Maple Leafs have raised significant questions regarding the team's performance, particularly in relation to their star player, Auston Matthews. Analysts are debating whether Matthews' recent dips in productivity are indicative of larger issues within the team dynamics or if the focus should shift towards coaching strategies employed by head coach Craig Berube. While Matthews has remained a key player, his inconsistency has been less than ideal for the Leafs, who are looking to solidify their positioning in the playoffs.

Critics point to various factors contributing to the Maple Leafs' challenges this season. The lack of goal support and defensive lapses have been highlighted, suggesting that Matthews alone cannot bear the weight of the team's expectations. Berube's tactical approach has come under scrutiny, with questions about whether his strategies truly leverage the talents of star players like Matthews effectively.

Meanwhile, the Maple Leafs' roster features other notable players who can contribute to turning the tide. Names like Mitch Marner and William Nylander are crucial in the conversation about the team's success. If they can elevate their game in conjunction with Matthews, the Leafs may find themselves back on track.

As the season progresses, both fans and analysts will be closely watching how the interplay between Matthews' role and Berube's coaching impacts the Leafs' performance. The quest for a deeper playoff run hinges on their ability to overcome these struggles and harness their full potential as a team.