Articles / Blue Jackets’ 5 Biggest Draft Busts of All-Time

Blue Jackets’ 5 Biggest Draft Busts of All-Time

T
The Hockey Writers
Jun 14, 2025 2:07 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →

The Columbus Blue Jackets have faced their share of disappointments in the NHL Draft, with several players failing to live up to expectations. Among the most notable busts is Alexandre Picard, who was selected 8th overall in 2004. Despite his promising start in junior hockey, Picard struggled to find his place in the NHL and played only a handful of games with the Blue Jackets before bouncing around to several other teams.

Another significant draft miss came in 2012 when the Blue Jackets chose Ryan Murray second overall. After a highly anticipated debut, Murray grappled with injuries that hampered his career and led to a lack of impact at the NHL level. While he undoubtedly showcased talent, the lofty expectations of a second overall pick left fans wanting more.

The failed selection of Nikita Filatov in 2008 further emphasizes the Blue Jackets' challenging draft history. Drafted 6th overall after an impressive junior career, Filatov's NHL tenure was disappointing, leading him to return to Europe just a few seasons in. His story serves as a reminder of how quickly promise can fade in the professional league.

More recently, the Blue Jackets selected Pierre-Luc Dubois third overall in 2016, a decision that sparked hope for the franchise. However, a fallout with the organization led to Dubois being traded to the Winnipeg Jets, leaving fans with unresolved feelings about his potential with Columbus. Furthermore, the drafting of the highly-touted Kuraev left fans wondering about the decision-making process as the team continues to seek true franchise-changing players.

Ultimately, these draft choices highlight the unpredictable nature of the NHL Draft. The Blue Jackets have experienced both heartache and hope in their quest to build a competitive roster through the draft, a journey that continues to evolve as they seek their next franchise cornerstone.