Articles / Flyers playing Nic Deslauriers against Oilers is a brutal mistake

Flyers playing Nic Deslauriers against Oilers is a brutal mistake

B
Broad Street Hockey
Nov 12, 2025 5:24 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Broad Street Hockey. Read the full original article here →

The Philadelphia Flyers' recent decision to deploy Nic Deslauriers against the Edmonton Oilers has sparked considerable debate among hockey fans and analysts. While Deslauriers is known for his physical play and toughness, his recent performances have raised questions about whether his presence on the ice is genuinely beneficial for the team. Critics argue that his limited offensive contributions could more harm than good, especially against a high-powered offense like the Oilers, led by star players such as Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl.

This choice to prioritize grit over skill seems misplaced, particularly when considering the Flyers' need for more scoring depth and playmaking ability. The Flyers have struggled this season, and relying on a player like Deslauriers may not address the core issues impacting the team’s performance. Fans are understandably frustrated as they hope to see a more effective lineup that can compete against elite opponents.

In contrast, some supporters argue that Deslauriers' physicality adds an essential element of energy to the team, potentially motivating his teammates and intimidating opponents. However, the question remains whether this impact can outweigh the potential downsides of his limited contributions on the scoresheet.

As the Flyers continue to navigate a challenging season, their tactics, including the decision to play Deslauriers, will be scrutinized. The team's management must evaluate whether maintaining a physical presence is the right strategy or if they need to pivot towards a more skilled approach to find consistent success in the NHL.