Articles / Lawyer: NHL teams to weigh talent against backlash after five players reinstated

Lawyer: NHL teams to weigh talent against backlash after five players reinstated

S
Sportsnet
Sep 12, 2025 12:06 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Sportsnet. Read the full original article here →

The NHL is currently assessing how to balance player talent with potential public backlash following the reinstatement of five players who were previously suspended. Among those reinstated are well-known players like Ivan Provorov and Erik Gudbranson, who have faced scrutiny for their off-ice actions. The league's decision comes at a time when franchises must prioritize team culture and community values while also considering the competitive edge these players may provide on the ice.

Teams are expected to take a closer look at not only the skills these players possess but also the implications of their past controversies. This creates a unique dilemma for general managers, who need to weigh the risk of alienating fans against the benefits of enhancing team performance. The conversation revolves around whether talent should outweigh potential backlash, especially in today’s social climate.

Across the league, executives are aware that a player's return can energize a team, but it can also spark reactions from fans and sponsors. This balancing act is more pertinent now than ever as teams navigate a new era of social responsibility and accountability. Ultimately, the decision will dictate how franchises are built and how players represent themselves both on and off the ice. The outcome of this situation could shape the NHL's approach to player conduct in the long term.