Oilers’ 3 Most Overrated Players for 2025-26
T
The Hockey Writers
Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →
In the world of hockey, perceptions can often become skewed, leading to certain players being labeled as overrated. The Edmonton Oilers have their fair share of players who fit this description, particularly as the new season approaches. One player to consider is Connor McDavid, whose immense talent often leads fans and analysts alike to overlook his defensive shortcomings. While McDavid is undoubtedly elite offensively, his inability to consistently contribute defensively can cause frustration for coaches and fans, especially in tight playoff situations.
Another player under scrutiny is Leon Draisaitl, whose goal-scoring prowess is well-known. However, some argue that his numbers are somewhat inflated due to playing alongside McDavid. Draisaitl's skill is undeniable, but questions about his impact in high-stakes games linger, with many feeling he thrives primarily within the Oilers' dynamic offensive system rather than as an individual star.
Lastly, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins finds himself in the conversation as an overrated player. Despite his longevity and ability to complement superstars, his overall consistency has been called into question. Some fans may see him as a key player, but others point out that he often disappears during critical moments, leading to the perception that he may not be living up to the high expectations set for him when he was drafted first overall.
Evaluating these players reveals the complexities of the game and how narratives can develop around performance. As the Oilers gear up for another season, discussions about who is overrated may shape fan expectations and drive conversations around the team's success in the NHL.
Another player under scrutiny is Leon Draisaitl, whose goal-scoring prowess is well-known. However, some argue that his numbers are somewhat inflated due to playing alongside McDavid. Draisaitl's skill is undeniable, but questions about his impact in high-stakes games linger, with many feeling he thrives primarily within the Oilers' dynamic offensive system rather than as an individual star.
Lastly, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins finds himself in the conversation as an overrated player. Despite his longevity and ability to complement superstars, his overall consistency has been called into question. Some fans may see him as a key player, but others point out that he often disappears during critical moments, leading to the perception that he may not be living up to the high expectations set for him when he was drafted first overall.
Evaluating these players reveals the complexities of the game and how narratives can develop around performance. As the Oilers gear up for another season, discussions about who is overrated may shape fan expectations and drive conversations around the team's success in the NHL.