Articles / Oilers Could Have Rewritten Their History by Drafting Matthew Tkachuk in 2016

Oilers Could Have Rewritten Their History by Drafting Matthew Tkachuk in 2016

T
The Hockey Writers
Jul 28, 2025 5:40 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →

In 2016, the Edmonton Oilers faced a pivotal decision during the NHL Draft, where they chose to select Jesse Puljujärvi with the fourth overall pick, bypassing Matthew Tkachuk. Tkachuk has since emerged as a formidable force in the NHL, showcasing skill and tenacity with the Calgary Flames. The Oilers, meanwhile, have struggled to find consistent scoring depth, which makes one ponder how different their franchise history could have been should they have opted for Tkachuk instead.

Since joining the league, Tkachuk has proven to be a player you build a franchise around. His ability to play a two-way game, combined with his knack for scoring and physicality, has made him a key player for the Flames. Critics argue that the Oilers missed a golden opportunity to bolster their roster, especially since Tkachuk's style of play could have complemented stars like Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl.

The narrative surrounding the 2016 Draft has been brought back to the forefront as both franchises have carved out their paths in the league. While the Oilers have experienced some highs, including playoff appearances, the question remains whether they could have found more sustained success by securing a player like Tkachuk. Fans and analysts alike continue to debate the impact this decision had on the Oilers’ recent history and team composition.

As both the Flames and Oilers continue to chase the ultimate goal of the Stanley Cup, this draft decision remains a talking point that reflects the volatility and unpredictability of the NHL Draft. The potential for what could have been adds an intriguing layer to the rivalry between these two Canadian franchises, ensuring that the 2016 Draft remains a defining moment in their respective histories.