Articles / Red Wings Could’ve Fixed Their Goaltending Issues in 2012

Red Wings Could’ve Fixed Their Goaltending Issues in 2012

T
The Hockey Writers
Dec 10, 2025 6:45 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →

In the summer of 2012, the Detroit Red Wings faced a pivotal moment in their franchise's history as they contemplated their goaltending situation. With long-time goalie Jimmy Howard set to enter free agency and a lack of suitable replacements, the team was at a crossroads. The post-lockout season had exposed gaps in the team's defensive strategy, prompting discussions about potential acquisitions that could bolster their chances for a championship run.

An intriguing possibility at the time was the availability of Jonathan Bernier, who was then a promising young talent with experience starting in the league. Bernier's skills could have complemented Howard, providing a solid one-two punch in net. The Red Wings' front office, however, hesitated, opting for a conservative approach that left them vulnerable in subsequent seasons.

As the years went by, Detroit's goaltending woes became increasingly apparent, with inconsistency in performance leading to missed playoff opportunities. The Red Wings watched as teams like the Chicago Blackhawks and the Tampa Bay Lightning thrived with strong goaltending duos. Ultimately, the decision to not act decisively in 2012 may have set the franchise back, as they struggled to find reliable netminders who could carry the team to the playoffs.

Reflecting on those decisions, it's clear that the Red Wings could have changed their trajectory by investing in the right goaltending options back in 2012. With a different approach, they might have revitalized their roster and maintained their status as a powerhouse in the NHL. The lessons learned from that summer should serve as a valuable guide for future strategies in pursuing championship contention.