Articles / Revisiting the Canadiens’ Jaroslav Halak-Carey Price Decision

Revisiting the Canadiens’ Jaroslav Halak-Carey Price Decision

T
The Hockey Writers
Jul 19, 2025 2:05 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →

In a recent reflection on the Montreal Canadiens' decision to trade Jaroslav Halak in 2014, the ramifications of that choice continue to echo in the franchise's history. At the time, Halak had emerged as a playoff hero, leading the Canadiens into the postseason with an impressive performance. His trade to the St. Louis Blues caught many by surprise, particularly as he had played such a crucial role in the team's playoff journey, earning accolades for his skill and determination on the ice.

Fast forward to the present, and the Canadiens are still grappling with the consequences of that trade, which also involved the decision to stick with Carey Price as the primary goaltender. Price has undoubtedly solidified his legacy with the franchise, becoming a cornerstone of the team's identity. However, the Canadiens have faced ongoing challenges, including injuries and inconsistent performances, that have made fans nostalgic for the Halak era.

As the Canadiens look to the future, the impact of both price and Halak's legacies will undoubtedly shape their decisions. The question remains, could the team have navigated their recent struggles differently had they kept Halak, or was the gamble on Price ultimately the right call? Considering both players' journeys, fans and analysts alike ponder what might have been if decisions had been made differently during that pivotal time in Canadiens' history. As the franchise seeks to build a more competitive roster, understanding past decisions and their long-term effects will be crucial in shaping the team's future direction.