Articles / Should You Take Devils' Jack Hughes Over Leafs' Auston Matthews? The Answer's Clear

Should You Take Devils' Jack Hughes Over Leafs' Auston Matthews? The Answer's Clear

H
Hockey News
Aug 21, 2025 11:44 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Hockey News. Read the full original article here →

In the ongoing debate about the superior choice between Jack Hughes of the New Jersey Devils and Auston Matthews of the Toronto Maple Leafs, the scales lean favorably towards Hughes. Both players have proven to be elite talents in the NHL, yet Hughes has consistently showcased an ability to elevate his game and lead his team. His vision on the ice, coupled with his exceptional skill set, has made him a pivotal player for the Devils, especially in crucial moments.

Auston Matthews, while undoubtedly a prolific goal scorer and a vital component for the Maple Leafs, has faced challenges in terms of consistency during the playoffs. Although Matthews is a dominant force during the regular season, Hughes' all-around game has allowed him to shine even more brightly during high-stakes situations.

As both players continue to evolve and develop their skills, the choice between them won't just hinge on statistics but on their overall impact on their respective teams. The potential for Hughes to outpace Matthews in dynamic playmaking and leadership is becoming increasingly evident as he continues to grow into his role with New Jersey.

Ultimately, the comparison between Jack Hughes and Auston Matthews is more than just a statistical analysis; it's about the future of their franchises and the difference each player can make as they pursue the ultimate goal of a Stanley Cup.