Articles / Sid the Kid vs. Super Mario: Crosby Still Falls Short

Sid the Kid vs. Super Mario: Crosby Still Falls Short

T
The Hockey Writers
Jun 13, 2025 4:22 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →

In the realm of hockey legends, Sidney Crosby and Mario Lemieux stand as two of the most iconic figures in Pittsburgh Penguins history. Both players not only left their mark on the franchise but also transformed the game itself. Crosby, known for his exceptional skill and leadership, has been a cornerstone for the Penguins since he was drafted first overall in 2005. His ability to perform under pressure and contribute in clutch situations mirrors much of what Lemieux demonstrated throughout his illustrious career.

Lemieux, revered for his size, skill, and innate playmaking abilities, was already a superstar by the time Crosby joined the league. His return from a series of health issues only solidified his status as one of the greatest players of all time. While their careers did not overlap significantly, Lemieux’s impact on the Penguins laid the groundwork for Crosby's success. Both players share a unique narrative woven through the fabric of Pittsburgh's hockey culture, inspiring a new generation of fans and players alike.

As the debate continues among fans regarding who might be the greatest of all time, it’s essential to recognize the contributions of both Lemieux and Crosby. They each brought a unique style to the ice, showcasing skills that not only won games but also influenced countless aspiring hockey players. Their respective legacies continue to be celebrated by fans and within the hockey community, serving as benchmarks of excellence in the sport. While comparisons are inevitable, the appreciation for their exceptional talents can be universally agreed upon, making them true legends of the game.