Surprise: great players rarely make great NHL coaches
D
Daily Faceoff
Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Daily Faceoff. Read the full original article here →
The debate over whether great NHL players can translate their skills into effective coaching positions has long been a topic of interest in the hockey community. Notable examples like Jon Cooper of the Tampa Bay Lightning and Rod Brind'Amour of the Carolina Hurricanes showcase that success on the ice doesn't always correlate with success behind the bench. Both coaches have successfully implemented winning tactics, drawing from their high-level playing experiences.
Cooper, who led the Lightning to back-to-back Stanley Cups, has often emphasized the importance of player relationships and understanding from a coach's perspective. Meanwhile, Brind'Amour’s innovation and commitment to a strong team culture have garnered respect, illustrating that having a solid foundational knowledge from one’s playing days can elevate coaching standards.
However, not every great player makes a successful coach. Figures like Joel Quenneville and Paul Maurice demonstrate the other side of the spectrum, often earning reputations that raise questions about their effectiveness when compared to their illustrious playing careers. It’s a nuanced discussion that considers factors beyond just prior playing talent, such as communication and adaptability.
Ultimately, the examples of successful coaches like Cooper and Brind'Amour suggest that while being a great player can provide insights into the game, a blend of managerial skills and emotional intelligence is vital for achieving success in coaching roles.
Cooper, who led the Lightning to back-to-back Stanley Cups, has often emphasized the importance of player relationships and understanding from a coach's perspective. Meanwhile, Brind'Amour’s innovation and commitment to a strong team culture have garnered respect, illustrating that having a solid foundational knowledge from one’s playing days can elevate coaching standards.
However, not every great player makes a successful coach. Figures like Joel Quenneville and Paul Maurice demonstrate the other side of the spectrum, often earning reputations that raise questions about their effectiveness when compared to their illustrious playing careers. It’s a nuanced discussion that considers factors beyond just prior playing talent, such as communication and adaptability.
Ultimately, the examples of successful coaches like Cooper and Brind'Amour suggest that while being a great player can provide insights into the game, a blend of managerial skills and emotional intelligence is vital for achieving success in coaching roles.