Articles / The Sad Reality of the Presidents’ Trophy “Curse”

The Sad Reality of the Presidents’ Trophy “Curse”

T
The Hockey Writers
Dec 4, 2025 4:35 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →

The NHL Presidents' Trophy is awarded to the team that finishes the regular season with the most points, but it comes with a peculiar reputation. Many teams that clinch this trophy struggle to make a significant playoff impact. For example, teams like the 2019 Tampa Bay Lightning, who had a historical season but were swept in the first round, have demonstrated that regular-season dominance does not guarantee playoff success.

Factors contributing to this phenomenon include increased pressure and expectations placed on the Presidents' Trophy winners. The players often face intense scrutiny from fans and media, which can create an overwhelming environment during the playoffs. The psychological aspect of the game intensifies, as these teams might feel the weight of their accomplishments hindering their performance when it matters the most.

Another consideration is injuries and fatigue. Competitive seasons can take a toll on players, and those who excel all season long may find themselves dealing with physical setbacks during the playoffs. The 2016 Washington Capitals experienced this when key players were sidelined, ultimately leading to their early exit despite being one of the best teams in the league.

Despite the setbacks, many fans continue to support their teams with unwavering loyalty. The Presidents' Trophy remains a coveted achievement, and fans hope for a reversal of fortune for their teams, as they await a season where the trophy winner can finally lift the Cup. The journey for teams like the Colorado Avalanche and Boston Bruins, who strive to break free from the so-called 'Curse,' remains a central theme for hockey aficionados.