Articles / Throwback Thursday: Looking at the Joe Nieuwendyk trade with the Stars

Throwback Thursday: Looking at the Joe Nieuwendyk trade with the Stars

F
Flames Nation
Nov 20, 2025 11:00 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Flames Nation. Read the full original article here →

The trade that sent Joe Nieuwendyk from the Calgary Flames to the Dallas Stars in 1995 remains one of the most pivotal moments in NHL history. Nieuwendyk, a talented center, was an integral part of the Flames' success during the early '90s, contributing to their Stanley Cup victory in 1989. However, as the Flames looked to rebuild, the franchise made the bold decision to part ways with him, trading him for defenseman Cory Stillman, a trade that would shape both franchises for years to come.

With the Stars, Nieuwendyk flourished, becoming a key player in their lineup. He went on to help lead the team to a Stanley Cup championship in 1999, solidifying his legacy as a clutch performer. Meanwhile, the Flames faced challenges in finding immediate success from the trade, as Stillman struggled to make a significant impact in Calgary.

In hindsight, while the Flames intended to gain an asset to complement their future, the loss of Nieuwendyk proved costly. He not only excelled on the ice but also became known for his leadership qualities, setting an example for younger players. The trade underscores the unpredictability of the NHL and the importance of timing and vision in a team's strategy.

As both teams look back on this trade, the impact of Nieuwendyk’s legacy continues to be felt. His journey through the league showcases the dynamic nature of player trades and their potential to alter the trajectory of franchises, leaving fans to ponder what might have been had he stayed in Calgary longer.