Articles / Trading Stuart Skinner Would Be the Oilers’ Biggest Mistake

Trading Stuart Skinner Would Be the Oilers’ Biggest Mistake

T
The Hockey Writers
Sep 1, 2025 6:15 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by The Hockey Writers. Read the full original article here →

The discussion around Stuart Skinner's potential trade has ignited passionate debates among Edmonton Oilers fans and analysts alike. As a young goaltender, Skinner has demonstrated considerable talent and promise since taking on a more significant role with the team. The Oilers, currently in a critical phase of their roster development, must weigh the implications of trading a player who could soon be a cornerstone of their goaltending future.

Skinner's performance has been closely monitored, particularly after noteworthy games where he showcased his ability to handle pressure. The argument for keeping him hinges on his growth trajectory and the fact that he could be a long-term solution in net for the Oilers. Trading him could not only undermine his development but also leave the team scrambling for reliable goaltending options in a league where solid netminders are in high demand.

Critics of a potential trade suggest that such a move would signal a lack of faith in Skinner's abilities. They argue that this would reflect poorly on the team's management and undermine the confidence of other young players. As the Oilers look to find success in the competitive Western Conference, keeping a player like Skinner might be the key to establishing a solid foundation for the future.

In conclusion, trading Stuart Skinner may be considered one of the Oilers' biggest mistakes. As he continues to develop and gain experience, the young goaltender is poised to become a valuable asset. The Oilers must carefully deliberate the future of their netminding situation, recognizing that Skinner's potential could be critical for their success in the seasons to come.

Players Mentioned