Articles / Who's The Great Pittsburgh Penguin Ever: Crosby Or Lemieux?

Who's The Great Pittsburgh Penguin Ever: Crosby Or Lemieux?

H
Hockey News
Oct 22, 2025 11:31 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Hockey News. Read the full original article here →

The debate over who is the greatest Pittsburgh Penguin—Sidney Crosby or Mario Lemieux—has captivated fans for generations. Both players have left an indelible mark on the franchise and the NHL as a whole, each excelling in different eras but consistently showcasing their immense talent and leadership on the ice.

Crosby, often dubbed 'Sid the Kid,' was drafted first overall in 2005 and quickly became the face of the franchise. His vision, playmaking abilities, and work ethic have led the Penguins to three Stanley Cup victories, establishing him as a modern-day legend. His commitment to the game and consistent performance have not only solidified his legacy in Pittsburgh but have also earned him admiration league-wide.

Meanwhile, Lemieux, who played most of his career in the 1980s and 1990s, had a unique playing style that combined grace and power, making him an electrifying presence whenever he took the ice. His incredible career was marred by health issues, yet he still managed to secure two Stanley Cups and has remained an influential figure in the organization, even serving as the team's owner.

The comparisons between the two legends are inevitable, with stats and accolades analyzed ad nauseam. While some fans swear by Crosby's playoff heroics, others support Lemieux’s remarkable scoring ability and the impact he had on hockey during his prime. Ultimately, whether you favor Crosby or Lemieux may depend on personal experiences as a fan, but both have undeniably shaped the identity of the Pittsburgh Penguins in their own unique ways.

As the Penguins continue to evolve, the conversation around who stands as the franchise's greatest player will persist, ensuring that both Crosby and Lemieux will forever be revered in Pittsburgh's rich hockey history.