Articles / Why Crosby's extra Cup is decider in Sid vs. Mario for greatest Penguin

Why Crosby's extra Cup is decider in Sid vs. Mario for greatest Penguin

S
Sportsnet
Dec 23, 2025 1:25 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Sportsnet. Read the full original article here →

The debate between Sidney Crosby and Mario Lemieux as the greatest player in Pittsburgh Penguins history is reignited with Crosby's recent achievements. Both players have solidified their legacies with impressive stats and championships, but Crosby's extra Cup pushes him to the forefront of this discussion. While Lemieux was a transformative player in the NHL, Crosby's consistent excellence and leadership on the ice have allowed him to carve out a place in history that some argue surpasses that of Lemieux.

Crosby's journey to greatness is marked by his ability to excel in crucial moments, leading his team during playoff runs and securing victories that cement the franchise's status. His skillset, including vision, passing, and scoring, showcases why he is often compared to Lemieux. The two players have different styles, yet their contributions to the Penguins franchise are monumental and deserve recognition during this comparison.

As Penguins fans weigh in on this debate, the admiration for both players remains strong. Lemieux, with his unique blend of power and finesse, revolutionized the position, while Crosby continues to exhibit remarkable play even as he ages in the league. Ultimately, the question of who holds the title of the greatest Penguin may never truly be resolved, but with Crosby's recent successes, he has undoubtedly placed himself in a conversation that shows no signs of quieting down anytime soon.