Articles / Why the eye test and his numbers suggest Stolarz left money on the table

Why the eye test and his numbers suggest Stolarz left money on the table

S
Sportsnet
Oct 2, 2025 4:26 PM

Summary: This is a summary of an article originally published by Sportsnet. Read the full original article here →

In the world of NHL goaltending, Anthony Stolarz stands out not just for his skills on the ice, but also for the intriguing intersection of his performance metrics and what many refer to as the 'eye test'. While traditionally, numbers like save percentage and goals against average are pivotal in assessing a goaltender's effectiveness, the subjective evaluation often reveals a different narrative. Stolarz, who has shown considerable promise with the Anaheim Ducks, seems to embody this duality, leaving many analysts to speculate whether he might be undervalued in the market.

As the NHL landscape evolves, the significance of both analytics and traditional scouting methods continues to be a topic of discussion among teams and fans alike. The Ducks, in particular, have benefited from Stolarz's unique abilities, showcasing his strength in high-pressure situations against formidable opponents. His performances raise questions about the financial valuation of goalies who can deliver under stress, contrasting with the more straightforward metrics that often dominate discussions.

Despite the potential stigmatization of a goaltender’s performance based solely on statistics, Stolarz’s playing style has garnered admirers who believe his nuanced understanding of the game could earn him more recognition and financial reward in future contracts. As he continues to hone his skills in a fiercely competitive league, the challenge remains for both players and franchises to strike the right balance between cold hard data and the undeniable art of goaltending.

In conclusion, the analysis of Anthony Stolarz's situation is emblematic of a larger conversation in the NHL about how teams value talent in an era deeply influenced by analytics. Whether Stolarz has indeed left money on the table remains to be seen, but his journey illustrates the complexities of modern hockey evaluation and the potential for goaltenders to receive the recognition they deserve.

Players Mentioned